Need --> Concept --> Specification
Need
Almost every product starts with the awareness of
a need, then an idea is conceived to address that need. With a little more
thought, and a few sketches the basic concept is born. There is a
perception that perhaps others may also share this need, and the inventor
sees an opportunity to bring a product to market.
Unfortunately there a a lot of time consuming, expensive
steps in the above process!
At this stage in the process it is important to
identify what the need actually is, and to be able to describe exactly
what problem your concept solves, the more detail can be provided at this
point, the less time and money will be wasted on sidetracks. All too often
the inventor is carried along with the novelty of their concept and loses
touch with the original problem.
An example of a needs statement
might be:
-
I need to be able to move heavy objects.
This is a bit vague, better if we can
identify the need (and perhaps niche market) in detail.
-
I need to be able to move objects of
100 to 500kg , of volume less than 1m^3
-
I need to move them across rugged terrain,
of distances of 1km
-
A speed of 10km/hr would be adequate
-
and I don't have electrical power nearby
Concept
Suddenly , in a flash of inspiration, you realise
"what
I need is an anti-gravity machine" and this becomes your
concept,
you race down to the patent office only to be disheartened to learn that
concepts can't be patented, only devices (that embody your concept) that
provide a solution to the problem. These devices must stand the tests of
inventiveness, novelty, and utility. So we need to flesh out the concept,
and the method by which it works. That last phrase is very important :
a method is required, and the device must work!.
The concept is usually drescribed by means of a
few hand sketches, suitably marked up with arrows and explanations;
and lists of features.
Perhaps we should be doing
a market survey at this point? Why bother? No-one else seems to! "Build
it, they will come" is the all too familiar catch cry.
So armed with several heavily scrawled over envelopes,
laden with illegible sketches and diagrams, our would be inventor stumbles
across his first hurdle: He has to get someone to build his device,
and so he approaches his local engineer.
The first thing he requires is a specification.
Specification
Perhaps the first specification went like this:
"Noah , make yourself a
boat, make rooms in it , and cover with tar inside and out.Make it 133metres
long, 22metres wide, and 13metres tall, Make a roof for the boat, and leave
a space of 44 cm between the roof and walls. Build it with three decks
and a door in the side. Take into the boat a male and female of of every
kind of bird and animal, and take along all kinds of food, to keep them
alive for forty days."
The important thing here, as with all specifications,
is to leave nothing nothing to chance, never assume the person reading
it has the same understanding as yourself. Punctuation can even be important,
if you want ten 3½" floppys , then ensure you don't inadvertently
write 103 ½" disks.
Even sizes can be ambiguous;
-
½" tube is sized on exact outside
diameter (and the ID may vary, eg 5/16")
-
½" hose is sized on exact inside
diameter (and OD may vary, eg 5/8")
-
½" pipe is sized on an exact OD
of 3/4", that gives an approximate bore of 1/2"
-
Electrical wire is spec'ed on the copper
wire diameter (or area) and not the diameter of the outer insulation.
The trend is to use tabular format , particularly for
numeric data, an example might be:
ARK project specification rev 1.0
| Material |
Clear Hardwood F6 or better |
|
| Size |
133m L x 22m W x 13m H |
|
| Roof |
Required , side clearance >0.44m |
|
| Decks |
3 |
|
| Access |
1 side door |
Downward hinging preferred |
| Waterproofing |
Tar inside and out per ANSI0001 |
|
| Load capacity |
2 of each species |
refer to species schedule 1 |
| Service life |
47days |
|
| Accommodation |
10 families |
Upper deck preferred |
|
|
|
As you can see this is a first pass, and there are some
points to be observed:
-
"jargon" words such as "clear" are
used, this does not mean "transparent" but "clear of knots"
-
a standardised rating is used "F6" for
the timber strength
-
we have omitted a few things, e.g. the
size of the door, we need to accomodate elephants and giraffes, and what
about toilet facilities?, propulsion system?, steering system?
-
a published standard is quoted "ANSI1234"
, it is important to ensure the standard is relevant, e.g. this standard
may have only described the color of the tar!
-
the load capacity is in end user terms,
an but engineer really needs to know the tonnage!
-
also omitted is any statutory compliance
that is required (e.g. EMC)
A good specification will go through several
iterations/negotiations/compromises, until the engineer is certain
he has something that can be built, and the client has something that will
do the job.
[ put in more
on elec engineering , and sample spec worksheet!]
See also
Full Project design
Firmware design
Circuit design
Mechanical design